data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d5393/d53936c6f559a2c93276adc9bdea83f82ba60695" alt=""
Review
by Stephen Thomas Erlewine
Officially released on CD late in 2008, long after his American Idol spotlight dimmed so dark he lost his major-label contract, Early Works reveals that Taylor Hicks was always a working musician, a no-fuss journeyman that cranked out soulful rock & roll, the kind that always sounds pretty good in a beer ad. That isn't much of a surprise: his Idol performances and post-Idolalbum suggested that he could always crank songs like "Soul Thing" and the softer "The Deal," a Bob Seger-styled midtempo number that surfaced on his major-label effort and is here in an early incarnation that isn't that much different. What's surprising about Early Works is its strain of sweet, folky singer/songwriter pop, halfway between Van Morrison and Stephen Stills. Most of the record is in this vein - possibly because it's a sound that's easier to market than the soul-rock that made his name - and while it's just as classic rock in its own way as the barroom blues boogie that brought him fame, it does suggest a depth not quite heard in his Idol-era performances. It's still journeyman stuff - music marked by its dogged devotion not divine spark - but it's well-done, heartfelt and endearing, sounding like the work of a local boy made good.
4 comments:
Good find, Griz!
Thanks for putting this up.
Fair and balanced....
Nice to read the good stuff!
Thanks for finding a review of EW. Can't remember if there have been others.
Always nice to hear good things about Taylor.
I'm also glad to hear there were no comparisons to other idols or people.
This is my favorite part,
"it does suggest a depth not quite heard in his Idol-era performances."
I suspect the new album will reveal even more of that depth.
Post a Comment